Showing posts with label bbc. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bbc. Show all posts

Thursday, 22 October 2009

BNP On Question Time


Having just watched the well built up appearance of Nick Griffin on Question Time, I was stuck firstly by the anti fascist groups trying to stop Griffin entering the BBC and the programme going ahead. I seriously question their anti fascist credentials on seeing such video, perhaps reading up on what fascism is may help, as that just ironic.

I did feel sceptical as to whether the programme would really be a debate, but David Dimbleby kept it on track well, particularly since the audience clearly wanted to string up Griffin by his testicles. I would have preferred the programme to focus on questions covering a range of topics, yet it is inevitable that the spot light would fall squarely on the BNP. There was too much interest for it not to.

Jack Straw was the weakest link, the question of whether "the success of the BNP can be explained by the misguided immigration policies of the government" just floored him, combined with Griffin's comments on the Iraq War, Straw really showed that this government can't defend it's record. Which hardly puts them in a strong position to challenge the BNP. Bonnie Greer was wonderful, when Nick Griffin was up against her he was really shown to be second-rate. I loved that she lectured him on British history, inviting him at one point to go to the British Museum to understand more.

Out of every one on the panel though it was David Dimbleby that real shone tonight, he threw the incriminating material at Nick Griffin and pushed him to explain it. Those were the times that Griffin really looked awful, loony, racist and embarrassed. I don't think just this alone will expose the BNP or change the mind of their votes, mainstream parties addressing people's alienation will, at least this is a start though.




Wednesday, 14 October 2009

Alcohol And The Brain - Horizon


Horizon was really interesting last night, it was about our relationship with alcohol. It was strange listening to it be compared to a drug, as that's not really the way I've ever thought of it. Particularly strange having a scientist speak about the effect it has on our minds, it targets the same parts as cocaine and heroin, remarkable.

It's an interesting idea within the programme with regard to each of us having an individual relationship with alcohol, from and formed when we are young right up until we die. It made me stop and think about mine, which isn't something you usually do outside of hugging the toilet and vomiting.

It's viewable on iPlayer for the next 5-7 days.




Sunday, 6 September 2009

BBC Question Time and the BNP


I'm glad to see the BBC are being objective about BNP. Whether people like it or not they have two elected MEPs. Given the BNP are often spoken about on Question Time, why shouldn't we debate their policies with them? Ignoring or protesting against them hasn't worked, what harm can this possibly do?

There is more good, they have never shared a platform with the main parties, they've never had to really debate and justify what they stand for. Will polices such as: Deport all the two million plus immigrates who are here illegally, really stand up to scrutiny? As how much will it cost to find 2 million people in terms of money and police resources? What about Griffin's sink the boats of immigrants policy? That's something surely to challenge.

Yet in doing this it's important to listen to them, there are reasons why people are voting for them. Understanding that is the best way to make progress.



Wednesday, 5 August 2009

Man on Wire


I just watched the documentary Man on Wire on the BBC's iplayer, it's about:
In August 1974, French wire-walker Philippe Petit spent nearly an hour walking, dancing, kneeling and lying on a wire which he and his friends had strung in secret between the rooftops of New York's Twin Towers. Six years of intense planning, dreaming and physical training fell into place that morning
It's a remarkable documentary, Philippe is a very engaging storyteller, he pulls you into his plan from the start, just as he did to those that helped him. He is enchanting, full of ego and self-confidence, brazenly well aware of the fact that he used people and then cast them aside. Yet as a policeman who arrested Philippe said, he knew he was seeing something unlike anything he'd ever see again. A true description of this film and Philippe Petit.



Monday, 13 July 2009

Gordon's Women


The Labour ladies have turned on Brown again, this time in "Gordon's Women" on radio 4. The programme explores whether or not Gordon has a problem working with women. I don't think it's a solely a female issue, Brown's problem is working with people that criticise him in general. This has increased as he's become more vulnerable, illustrated by his cabinet reshuffle being basically an act of putting up the barricades.

Opinion in the programme was divided, yet it's public opinion that matters. Does the term "window dressing" resonate with female voters? Deborah Matison, who studies public opinion for Gordon Brown didn't seem to think so, she said:
Women voters see him as a strong reliable sort of guy.
I'm not so sure she's really tapping into public opinion there, I think I would be inclined to call her bluff.



Saturday, 11 July 2009

O/T Torchwood - Children of Earth - Spoliers


It was an emotional roller-coaster with moments of brilliance and sadly written with skill I've not seen Russell T Davies apply to Doctor Who. The kids being taken away by the army was some of the best drama I've seen on the BBC in years. It was all too real as those trucks and buses pulled into the school. While the teachers were powerless to do anything but just insist that the soldiers don’t have the right to take the kids.

Finding out the 456 motives - drug dealing on an intergalactic scale - was a bit strange, part of me sniggered and part thought it was twisted. It does open up some big plot holes though, why did they come to earth in the 60s for the children? They couldn't have known the kids were drugs, were they just sniffing around for a dealer. Which lends to questioning why the government just shut out Torchwood from the start? There was a collective shrug as they resigned themselves to doing whatever the 456 said.

Overall I do feel torn in my reaction, as it's Torchwood, someone from the team is meant to pull the short straw and sleep with the bald three headed telekinetic chicken with a mucus problem. No one expects an Eastenders Christmas special, it was drama with a bit of sci-fi, instead of what it's been for the last two years, sci-fi with a bit of drama. If Torchwood didn't have a history this would have been brilliant, instead it's a little disappointing and really depressing.

Is this the end of Torchwood? Certainly as we know it, perhaps that won't turn out to be a bad thing, if they introduce some of the characters from this series.



Tuesday, 7 July 2009

No 10's Garden Room Girls


The Garden Room Girls are an elite band of secretaries that work for the prime minster. The BBC have interviewed some of them, Ann Finchett recalls:
Her clearest memories are of working for Winston Churchill, who would often dictate while he lay in bed. "He had a budgerigar which used to fly about his bedroom," remembers Ann. The bird would land in her lap and start nibbling the edges of the paper. "I often wondered what ministers made of the letters they used to get with bits taken out of them."
That's wonderful, I love those sort of details in history, it seems less distant and remote.

For those interested the documentary will be on BBC radio 4.



Sunday, 5 July 2009

John Major Interview - Government Machine



John Major made some good points in an interview with Andrew Marr, one point he made was that this is a real opportunity to address the states expansion (4:20). I like the idea of using this political atmosphere to cut the expense and power of the government machine, though obliviously it will take more than just that to address national debt. Quite where the line is drawn I'd like to see start being debated, instead of the rubbish that currently is, it's becoming like a time warp. Brown really doesn't present himself to be the future of Britain with this silly "cuts vs investment" rhetorical, more that he represents the past. Let alone that it really says something when John Major seems more radical than Gordon Brown.

This could be an interesting new narrative, as I doubt there are many people who are content with the current level of "nanny government", the Tories and Lib Dems could really gain from taking this line, as Labour are the cause of it. How do they defend that? It's for our own good because we can't be trusted to make decision for ourselves.....



Sunday, 31 May 2009

Brown and His Presbyterian conscience


Brown came out of the bunker today to do an interview with Andrew Marr. I had to skip a lot of it as he kept having a me, me, me moment. He did make one astute comment:
What I have seen offends my Presbyterian conscience; what I have seen is something that is appalling
Indeed, a lot of people feel that way about New Labour. Brown does have a tendency to use his background like a trump card or a shield. Though I fail to see why it automatically makes him moral or have a conscience. When it's something he's failed to actually prove.

He used the interview to announce his plans for a MP code of conduct, the BBC say it's:
thought likely to include minimum service commitments to constituents, with those who break it facing possible fine or even ejection from their seats
Why not just choose better candidates? To paraphrase David Mitchell it's like complaining about the pee in the swimming pool, when you've been the one peeing in it. You are not going to claim for silly things if voters will see it, put MP's expenses on-line and get rid of safe seats motiving people to work for votes. Give MPs who perhaps aren't naturally inclined to put people above the party, a push in the right direction. Yet that of course will put Labour at more of a disadvantage in the election, so that won't happen.

Yet perhaps my unease comes from the words Constitution and New Labour in the same sentence. As Brown is also setting up a committee to look at wider constitutional reforms, such as a bill of rights, a written constitution and House of Lords reform. New Labour have a real "gift" of making broadly defined laws that are never used for there original purpose and making things conditional rather than constitutional. This sounds like it could become one more thing to add to the list.

While all this reform is taking place though, where does this leave Sir Christopher Kelly? What happens if his report disagrees with Browns reform ideas? And more importantly when we will see an end to this saga?



Wednesday, 13 May 2009

Brown Gets "Extreme" on all MPs' Claims



Interesting that he's announced this again without talking to all parties concerned, and two senior MPs told the BBC:
The committee only agreed to examine the idea of an independent audit, that there was no "firm or final agreement" and would meet again on Wednesday after seeking advice on whether it was possible.
Could this be another saga within a saga?


Tuesday, 5 May 2009

European Elections 2009 - Party Pledges

I got my polling card through for the forthcoming EU elections, spurring me into researching the parties standing. Which has been surprisingly difficult just to find a list of who's involved. I did come across a good website in my search for information, EU Profiler, you answer a few questions and it charts your position against the main EU parties.

I've gathered together the information I did find with regard to the key party pledges, in alphabetical order:
  • BNP - Opposed to the Euro, wants withdrawal from the European Union, greater national self-sufficiency, promote trading ties with Australia, Canada and New Zealand.
  • Conservatives - If the Lisbon Treaty is not yet in force they will give a referendum on it, amend the 1972 European Communities Act so that any future EU Treaty would be subject to a referendum, opposed to the Euro, do not want to withdraw from the EU.
  • English Democrats - Referendum on whether to stay in the EU, though they are committed to keeping free trade arrangements by rejoining the European Free Trade Association (EFTA), opposed to the Euro.
  • Green Party - Invest in tackling climate change and renewable energy resources, opposed to the Euro, supports the EU membership though wants more accountability and reform within it.
  • Labour - Does not want to withdraw from the EU, wants further enlargement of the EU i.e Turkey to join, invest in tackling climate change, work to liberalise world trade.
  • Lib Dems - Focus on environmental policies, agricultural expenditure, completion of the Single Market, supports the EU membership though wants more accountability and reform with in EU.
  • Libertas - Supports the EU membership though wants to reform the EU, stop the waste, corruption, return control to the member nations. They have candidates standing in all 27 countries.
  • No2EU - Keep Britain out of the Eurozone, reject the Lisbon Treaty, protect the rights of British workers, defend and develop manufacturing, agriculture and fishing industries.
  • Plaid Cymru - Does not want to withdraw from the EU, wants Wales to achieve full membership as a member-state of the EU, wants a more accountable EU.
  • SNP - Referendum on the Lisbon Treaty, wants Scotland to achieve full membership as a member-state of the EU, fisheries under national control.
  • The Jury Team - Referendum on the EU, take a strong line on corruption and sleaze in the EU.
  • UKIP - Opposed to the Euro, wants withdrawal from the European Union to revert back to European Economic Community, no to green policy taxes.
  • UK First party - Replace Britain’s membership of the EU with a Free Trade agreement, review all EU-imposed legislation scrapping anything that is not in Britain’s interest.
This is to the best of my knowledge the English, Welsh and Scottish parties standing, I couldn't find much information on Northern Ireland ones. Hopefully more information will be forthcoming nearer the election, it's pretty non-existent at the moment.

Further information on your current MEP can been found on the EU website.

Update: The BBC have a handy election page up now. Which covers all parties campaigning and news, you can view it here.

Update 2: Another handy website - Vote Match answer questions to see how you compare to political parties.


Friday, 1 May 2009

The Prime Ministers


Nick Robinson has done a very interesting series that examines how, over three centuries, the occupants of Ten Downing Street have used - and misused - political power. It's quite remarkable that in 300 years not a lot has changed.

You can listen to the series on the BBC website.


Saturday, 18 April 2009

Henry VIII Jousting Accident Tyrant

There's an interesting article on the Independent site, about Henry VIII personality changing due to a jousting accident, which turned him from a relativity nice chap as Kings go, into the tyrant remembered by history:
"After the accident he was unconscious for two hours; even five minutes of unconsciousness is considered to be a major trauma today." Henry may have suffered a brain injury, Dr Worsley says. "Damage to the frontal lobe of the brain can perfectly well result in personality change."(read more)
That's quite an interesting theory, I'm reminded of a documentary on the BBC about Walter Freeman who horrifically preformed frontal lobotomies on patients. Howard Dully who was one of the people Freeman performed this on, afterwards found his behaviour became uncontrollable and erratic. Doctors in the documentary said it because the frontal lobes assist in planning, coordinating, controlling and executing behaviour and judgement. It also controls social and sexual behaviour.

So the theory seems sound, just not as exciting as thinking of him as a tyrant though.

A link to an overview of
Howard Dully and Walter Freeman, though I forewarn they do have picture on the page of the lobotomy being preformed, and they explain how he did it.


Thursday, 16 April 2009

Nurse struck off for whistle-blowing NHS

A nurse who secretly filmed for BBC Panorama to reveal the neglect of elderly patients at the Royal Sussex Hospital, has been struck off for misconduct by the Nursing and Midwifery Council. The panel ruled that Margaret Haywood "followed the behest of the filmmakers... rather than her obligations as a nurse" they went on to say:
Although the conditions on the ward were dreadful, it was not necessary to breach confidentiality to seek to improve them by the method chosen.
Margaret Haywood was a nurse for over 20 years, it was clearly a decision she didn't undertake lightly. She said that she'd expressed her concerns both to her immediate line manager and to her ward manager, but they did nothing. She would have been failing in her duty of care as a nurse, to close her eyes and keep drawing her salary, as the other nurses and managers did at that hospital.

More importantly she wouldn't have had to risk her job if management listened to staff concerns, if this culture of "there are things will don't speak of" didn't run through the NHS. It's completely disgraceful that it's cost Ms Haywood her job, her intentions clearly were for the right reasons. As sadly would conditions at that hospital have improved, without Panorama doing a programme on it.



Tuesday, 17 March 2009

Tuition Fees – Money, Money, Money


Tuition fees have to be reviewed by the government this year, and a survey by the BBC reports that universities want fees increased to between £4,000 and £20,000 per year. Of the vice chancellors interviewed two thirds believed fees had not deterred applications from poorer families.

I went to university a few years after means-tested tuition fees were introduced, the amount of financial help given by the government was judged on my parents income before tax. The government isn't digging deep in their pockets to help people out, they're making it as difficult as they can for people to claim anything.

The idea that it hasn't put people from lower incomes off is ridiculous, could people from lower incomes seriously consider becoming a doctor or vet with a potential £21,000 commitment, even before student loans and interest added? Raising it to the £7,000 suggested will make it a £42,000 commitment before loans and that's not going to put people off?

I'm not idealistic enough to say there should be no financial commitment from people in university, as there are so many people going onto higher education now. I accept it costs the government a lot of money, but there are ways for it work without penalising people. Especially since higher education has filled the role of apprenticeships, leaving people with few options.

Labour need to look at the system that's in place. Moving courses to colleges or adult learning that are just interest based would save money and resources. Quality not quantity is needed, this is far more important than targets that no one other than Labour care about. Higher education should be available to everyone, not just the privileged. Increasing tuition fees will just create even more of a divide between lower and higher income earners.




Sunday, 15 March 2009

Can Torture Ever Be Justified?

I was reading 'have your say' on the BBC, the question posed was; Can torture ever be justified? This question was raised in relation to Binyam Mohamed, who spent six years in Guantanamo Bay. The top comment recommended by 478 people as of writing this was:
My heart bleeds for him - not. He should be put back on a plane and sent "home". Why on earth the taxpayer is paying for this "resident" is beyond me. He can sue if he likes from where he comes from at his countrys expense - NOT OURS.
If he seeks "true Islam" then what is he doing here? Cashing in as usual...
I read four pages of comments and they were all in a similar vein. Putting aside his citizenship status as that is a separate issue. It shocks me that people can be so complacent about torture, comments like:
Oh yes. We're playing a dirty game against dirty players. If we have to win by using their own rules against them, so be it.

I dont know what he's complaining about. He should be thankful that he is still alive and he has still got a head and limbs.

Those men in Guantanamo Bay and other prisons, may or may not be guilty of any crime, but the moment they were tortured the ability to prosecute them was forfeited. As information or testimonies gained through torture isn't admissible in our courts.

So what about the credibly of the information. Is it a way to secure accurate and actionable information. Granted there is not a clear cut answer to that question, just searching for information on the web, examples can be found to support both sides of the argument. All studies agree though that people can confess or say anything in order to get the physical or mental torture to stop. That can easily lend to false information.

It's instinctive to get angry and want to retaliate, but where does this end if you say it's OK to torture someone under these circumstances, or we start to justify it in our own minds. It lessen the value of peoples lives, it's divisive, it is shameful, and what's point in it when we can't prosecute any one, does that really reflect the values of the West? I truly hope not, particularly when this looks so similar to the terrorist videos we see on our own screens.


Friday, 27 February 2009

New Cbeebies Presenter

There's an article on the BBC about the new Cbeebies presenter Cerrie Burnell, who was born without a right hand. It raises some interesting points about how people react to disability. The article says that though there has been a lot of support for Cerrie Burnell:
“...a minority of parents expressed concern that Ms Burnell's appearance was "scaring" children. One father said he feared it would give his daughter nightmares and a mother said her two-year-old girl could not watch because she thought the presenter had been hurt.”

The presenter says in relation to these concerns from parents and addressing disability with their children:

“It's a totally personal thing and people have to do it when they feel comfortable to do it. But I would just hope that, I guess, me being on CBeebies would present an opportunity for them to do that in the comfort of their own home.”

I certainly agree it's a better to address the question within the home, rather than how children usually do it! The idea though that she's scaring children just seems ridiculous, “my child is scared of watching because she thought the presenter was hurt”, isn't that just your inability to communicate to your child properly? It's like calling death “going to sleep and not waking up” and then wondering your child doesn't want to sleep at night, they just lay there crying softly.

Disability is a fact of life, from being in an accident to being born with a mental or psychical disability. If we were more open about this, wouldn't make it easier on everyone. As I think for a majority of people, you just don't know how to react to disability. It's not something that a large amount of people have been exposed to. But giving disability a platform and visibility like this is a good place to start.

So I say right on Cerrie!


Monday, 23 February 2009

Elizabeth's Super Gun

There's an interesting article on the BBC about two cannons that were recovered from an Elizabethan warship. During Elizabeth's reign the English Navy were greatly feared, but historians couldn't clearly show why this was, until now.

The cannons that were recovered from the wreak, were reconstructed and historians believe that Elizabeth changed English warships to have guns, of uniform size, firing rates and standard ammunition. The benefit of this is it's more effective to have lots of small guns, all the same and firing all at once.

Timewatch did firing tests on the replica gun, which showed the cannonballs were travelling at almost the speed of sound, estimating that they could hit a target about a mile away, and puncher right through a ship at 100 yards. The historians involved say this made the English Navy 50 years ahead of their time technologically.

Which goes some way to explaining the mystery of why Elizabeth's fleet were able to the defeat the Spanish Armada, even though they were out numbered by 200 ships to 130.